Canadian criminal record check results, explained
A result is not a pass or fail. It is a comparison between what the candidate declared and what the search returned. "Negative" sounds like bad news and means the opposite. "Incomplete" sounds like a red flag and usually is not one. Here is every result you can see, and what to do next.
The 2 searches that produce a result
A Canadian criminal record check can include either or both. They are independent: a candidate can be Negative on the basic check and Not Clear on the enhanced check, or the other way around.
Basic check
A CPIC search, matched against the declaration
A search of the Canadian Police Information Centre database for criminal convictions, compared against what the candidate declared.
A Vulnerable Sector Check is a separate process
It can only be run by a police service, and no screening provider in Canada can complete one on your behalf. If a role requires one, the candidate applies through their local police.
Basic check results
Three possible labels. The report extracts below are illustrations, built with sample data.
Nothing was found
This is the clean result. Think of it the way you would a medical test: negative means nothing turned up.
Both of these are true
- The candidate declared no criminal convictions.
- The search returned no criminal convictions.
The declaration and the record line up
The candidate declared 1 or more convictions, and the search confirmed them.
What it tells you
This result is about accuracy, not character. It says the candidate was upfront and that what they told you is correct.
Whether the record matters to the role is a separate hiring decision, and it is covered further down this page.
The two sides do not line up
The declaration and the search results disagree, or the search could not be closed out on name and date of birth alone.
Incomplete is not the same as a criminal record. Common names, name changes and data entry differences all produce it. Read the comments field before drawing any conclusion, and expect to go back to the candidate.
Common reasons
- The candidate declared no convictions, but the search returned 1 or more.
- The candidate declared convictions, and the search returned records that do not match what was declared. This can go either way, more records than declared or fewer.
- Details such as name, date or court location do not match the search results.
- The candidate declared convictions, and the search returned nothing.
- The search could not be completed on name and date of birth. Fingerprints are the next step.
Want to see your own result first?
If you are the one being screened, you can run your own Canadian criminal record check with MyCheck and see exactly what an employer would see. Online, no police station, no appointment.
Enhanced check results
Two labels, and the second one is the most misread result on any report.
The search returned nothing
No local police records surfaced against the candidate. Paired with a Negative basic check, it closes the file as Cleared.
The search returned 1 or more results
Not Clear does not mean a conviction. Most of the items listed below are not convictions at all. The report tells you what was found so you can assess it against the role.
What a Not Clear result can include
- Summary conviction offences
- Pending charges
- Conditional and absolute discharges
- Wanted and accused person information
- Pending probation information
- Pending court orders and undertakings
- Pending release conditions
- Pending diversions such as restorative justice
- Persons of special interest to police
- Deportation orders
- Illegal entry charges from the CBSA
- Charges stayed of proceedings
How the 2 results combine
Every check closes as either Cleared or Review. Only a Negative basic check closes as Cleared, and only when the enhanced check comes back Clear or was not ordered.
Everything else routes to Review, which means a person needs to look at it. Review is a routing label, not a verdict.
| Basic check | Enhanced check | Overall |
|---|---|---|
| Negative | Clear | Cleared |
| Negative | Not ordered | Cleared |
| Negative | Not Clear | Review |
| Confirmation of a Criminal Record | Any, or not ordered | Review |
| Incomplete | Any, or not ordered | Review |
What a Canadian criminal record check looks like
A completed check arrives as a dated certificate. Change the result below and the certificate rewrites itself, so you can see exactly which combinations close as Cleared and which route to Review.
Based solely on the name(s) and date of birth provided and any criminal record information declared by the applicant, a search of the RCMP National Repository of Criminal Records did not identify any records.
No records found in PSP/RMS, local police indices or local court registries.
issuing service
Negative and Clear is the only combination that closes as Cleared. Nothing here needs a human.
How to read it
- 1Applicant informationThe name, date of birth and address the search was run against, and the identity document used.
- 2Basic checkThe CPIC search result, stated against the RCMP National Repository, with its comments field beneath.
- 3Enhanced checkOnly present when an enhanced check was ordered. Local police indices and court registries.
- 4Issuing agencyThe police service that issued it, the date, the serial number and the officer ID.
An illustration, not a copy of a real certificate. Every provider and police service lays it out differently, but the information is broadly the same: who was searched, what was searched, the result, and who issued it.
The badge is drawn as a placeholder here on purpose. On a real certificate the crest of the issuing police service sits in that spot. Which service it is varies: any accredited Canadian police service can issue the check, and it depends on the partnership behind it.
What to do with a Review result
A Review result does not disqualify anyone. It asks you to make a decision. A workable process looks like this.
Read the comments field first
It usually explains the gap in 1 or 2 lines.
Confirm identity
A large share of Incomplete results come down to matching the right person, not to a record. Identity verification runs alongside the criminal check and resolves this quickly.
Go back to the candidate
Give them the chance to explain a discrepancy or correct a detail. Most are resolved in a single conversation.
Assess relevance to the role
A 12 year old offence unrelated to the job is not the same as a recent, directly relevant one. Write down your reasoning.
Apply your policy consistently
Whatever you decide, the same standard has to apply to every candidate for that role.
Human rights legislation in several provinces restricts what employers can do with certain records, including pardoned convictions and provincial offences. Requirements vary by province and by role, and this page is not legal advice. If you are building a screening policy, run it past your own counsel.
Questions candidates actually ask
If you are the person being screened, this section is for you. A criminal record check looks at police and court records. It does not look at your phone, your browser, or your personality.
What a record check actually looks at
Do they look at my search history?
Can they see my Yelp reviews, my posts, or my old tweets?
Minor incidents, tickets and fines
I got a warning from a police officer. Does that show up?
Do parking tickets show up on a background check?
Does a library fine count as a criminal record?
I got escorted out of a store. Is that a criminal record?
Charges that never became a conviction
I was arrested but never charged. Does that count?
My charge was withdrawn or dismissed. Will an employer see it?
What about a pardon, or a record suspension?
Do youth records show up?
Records from elsewhere, and seeing your own
Will convictions from another country show up?
Can I see my own result before an employer does?
Still stuck on something? The applicant help centre answers the practical questions about consent, documents and timing, and it is written for candidates rather than employers.
Questions employers ask
Is a Negative result bad?
Does Incomplete mean the candidate lied?
Does a criminal record automatically rule a candidate out?
What happens if fingerprints are required?
Can Credibled run a Vulnerable Sector Check?
How long does a Canadian criminal record check take?
Two ways to run a check
Pay per check either way. No subscription, no minimum.
Get your own check online with MyCheck. No police station, no appointment.
Run my check